The Report With No Data: Notes on Verification in Esports
That night, I received a nine-page file. The first page carried a warning abo...
That night, I received a nine-page file. The first page carried a warning about input integrity. The next nine pages were the familiar nine dimensions of an esports evaluation process: patch and meta, tournament system, teams and players, regional landscape, club finance, rules and governance, risk profile, public narrative, and the industry transmission chain. Every cell bore the same line: "Insufficient information."
No game title. No team. No player. Not a single number.

The person who sent the file was a young editor. He added one sentence: "Could you check whether the system failed?" I read all nine pages. The system had not failed. The report was being honest.
There is a paradox in my profession: an empty report is the most hated report, and also the most honest one. In a transfer window where hundreds of rumors are pushed out every hour, a sheet of paper saying "I do not know" is almost a countercultural act.
I once sat at the edge of a running track and learned the opposite lesson. In 2026, at the Sichuan provincial youth athletics championship, I followed a 1500m runner named Lam Phong. He finished seventh in 4:05.68, 2.1 seconds behind the champion. No camera turned toward him. I spent the whole evening listening to him describe training in a park at 5 a.m., because there was no track to use. The seventh-place finisher also has a line with his name on the running path. My two-thousand
